QUOTE(Robodoc @ Jun 14 2008, 08:53 PM)

QUOTE(pianosb @ Jun 14 2008, 08:04 PM)

Wow I've just checked out those wrists....How on earth can she play with her wrists so low?? Annoying when they set up the pose and get the position so wrong!!
Posture is such a variable thing: I know we are all taught a "right" way to sit and a "right" position for the wrists, but have you ever seen a video of Glenn Gould and looked at his position? He looks like (and probably was) the model for Dr Bob in the Muppets! Brilliant he may have been, but as well as not copying his tempi don't copy his posture . . .
(N.B. Piano Day, -9)
If you are brilliant enough you can get away with anything. Look at how Hurricane Higgins played snooker. But you would not copy it! Not if you have any sense. I'd make two points about these unorthodox techniques. Gould passionately believed that a low seat, hence low elbows and low wrist was a more "correct" way to play - resulting in pulling the keys down from below, rather then pressing them down from above. Most pianists would disagree. It is possible to be sitting too high, and to correct that fault, without going to Gouldian extremes.
1. If you change one part of the "orthodox" technique you have to change everything else to compensate. Would you also copy Gould's habit of swaying his upper body in a clockwise circle, or "singing" while recording? If you plan to copy Glenn Gould at all copy his defiant originality (i.e. be yourself), his love and understanding of Music, or his sound.
2. Unorthodox techniques are fragile. If it goes wrong it is much harder to repair. Again - in the world of snooker it is Steve Davis and Steven Hendry with their classically correct cue action that have had the long careers.
QUOTE(Robodoc @ Jun 14 2008, 08:53 PM)

. . . On the other hand, who am I to criticize Glenn Gould!!

A good musician and pianist with a fine mind!