QUOTE(primrose @ Feb 15 2008, 10:08 PM)

QUOTE(rosfrog @ Feb 15 2008, 08:50 PM)

You should be able to put it on your shoulder and put your left arm out, grab the scroll and hold it in your fingers with a slight bend in your arm.
Isn't the length of your fingers also relevant? I got a 17 inch viola because my arms are very long, but my little finger is quite short and I think I may have to downsize.
If you can hold the scroll in your fingers, you should be ok, but you're right that scale length comes into play (rather than finger length - you can get shorter scale lengths on longer instruments if that makes sense) - I made exactly the same mistake as you - had a 17 inch, struggled like mad to get my fourth finger in tune, then gave up and bought a 16,5 inch and the problem disappeared!
Best thing all round is to have a luthier look at you when you're trying them out, I reckon.