QUOTE(AmandaL @ Oct 19 2007, 10:12 AM)

QUOTE(fsharpminor @ Oct 19 2007, 08:40 AM)

I am a pianist rather than violinist but have played most of the Beethoven Sonatas. The Spring is probbaly Grade 7-8 to play completely.
Grade 7 or 8?.... and the rest. The AB have (rather unwisely perhaps) put the first movement of the Op. 96 violin sonata on the new Grade 8 syllabus. I was talking with (orchestral) colleagues about it the other week and we thought it was a ludicrous thing to expect someone to play coming up to Grade 8.
Beethoven sonatas are standard repertoire and fit into the diploma level categories.
At Grade 3 standard there is no shame in struggling - you are probably doing your playing more harm than good at this stage by fighting with them. Put them away for the time being and revisit when your skills have developed further.
Well, I usually play these with my daughter, and she never got beyond Grade 8. We cant touch the Kreutzer (no9) or no 10, but play the first six and no 8 reasonably well.
Some of the movements have been in Grade 7 or 8 in the past eg Rondo from no 3 was in Grade 8 for 2004-5 (though there is a misprint as it says in Bflat when it is in Eflat) . Rondo from No 1 was in Grade 7 for 2001-2002, and in the same year the Rondo from no 3 was in Grade 8. The previous syllabus (1990-2000) actually has the Spring (no 5), movements 1 or 4 in Grade 8 (also the F major Romance). Going back further the first and third movement of No 8 are in Grade 8 syllabus (1995-6)
I rest my case ! I did only suggest to Lottie she looks at selected movements.